Three men have been jailed for what has been described as an ‘extraordinary’ and elaborate kidnapping plot where they deliberately lured a London-based Israeli music producer to a remote location in Carmarthenshire using the ruse that he was going to attend a music recording camp in Wales to work with other musicians.

Each of the men have been jailed for eight years and one month respectively for deliberately enticing the victim Itay Kashti to a remote location, and once there subjecting him to significant violence and restraining him by handcuffs.

Mohammad Comrie, aged 22, of Leeds; Faiz Shah, aged 22, of Bradford; and 20-year-old Elijah Ogunnubi-Sime of Croydon, deceived the London-based music producer into travelling to west Wales on the 26 August 2024 where they kidnapped and assaulted him. During the assault, the victim received injuries to his face and head.

cottage
Itay Kashti was attacked and tied to a radiator in this remote cottage (CPS)

The defendants arranged for the producer to travel to Carmarthenshire using the ruse that he was going to attend a music recording camp in Wales to work with other musicians, arranged by what he believed to be a legitimate music production and recording company.

When the defendants left the room where they had detained him, the victim was able to escape by lifting his handcuffed hands up a pole and freeing himself from the location, and then ran out of the property. He was taken to hospital as a result of the incident.

The three men had fled the property but were located later that same evening following deployment of significant police resources, including a police helicopter, after police responded to reports of an assault at a property in the Brynteg area of Llanybydder. They were hiding in the fields surrounding the property.

Police recovered rubber masks which the kidnappers bought
Police recovered rubber masks which the kidnappers bought (CPS)

All three were arrested and subsequently charged. They pleaded guilty to kidnapping on the first day of their trial at Swansea Crown Court on February 18.

The other counts the defendants were facing - unlawful wounding and inflicting grievous bodily harm with intent - were ordered to lie on file.

Today Mohammad Comrie was sentenced to eight years and one month imprisonment, Faiz Shah was sentenced to eight years and one month imprisonment, and Elijah Ogunnubi-Sime was sentenced to eight years and one month detention in a young offenders institution.

Inspector Gareth Jones, Deputy Senior Investigating Officer said: “It is clear that this offence has had a profound, harrowing and lasting impact on the victim and his family. This crime was thoroughly planned and was sophisticated in elements, including the use of false identities.

“At an early stage during their messaging to each other it was clear that their ultimate intention was the kidnap of the victim. The motivation appears two-fold, firstly, they clearly intended to extort money from the victim and additionally there was also political and racial motivation.

“I would like to thank everyone who has been involved in bringing this case to court, particularly the investigation team for their tenacity and professionalism and the resolute and tireless efforts of the officers at the scene in locating the defendants after a prolonged and difficult search and recovering crucial evidence. Securing justice for the victim has been our priority throughout.

Police recovered this air pistol from the rural cottage where the gang held their victim
Police recovered this air pistol from the rural cottage where the gang held their victim. (CPS)

“I would also like to thank the Community Security Trust (CST) for supporting the victim following this harrowing incident, which included providing both vital psychological and emotional support.

“This sentence today reflects the severity of this offence and the ordeal the victim suffered – and we hope it gives the victim a sense of justice. We thank him for his strength, bravery and patience whilst we carried out a thorough investigation into what was an extraordinary crime.”